Showing posts with label energy use. Show all posts
Showing posts with label energy use. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

November Board Highlights from OEA

Board Study Session on Facilities: 
(topics covered: AC, Solar, Energy Efficiencies & Prop 39, Portables, total Project list & New projects)

November Board Highlights
Video link part 1
Video link part 2

Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB) account to pre-fund post-employment benefits
Cost to district of OPEB is @$457,000. per year and has been ear-marked in he general fund. About 36 districts in CA use irrevocable trust accounts to fund this. OUSD lawyers have not reviewed the agreement and will not be included in decision-making.

Trustee Rossiter wants to take a prudent approach and deposit @$150,000 and leave it to roll forward and pay the $457,000 from the general fund. The $150,000 represents a 1% cost for all teachers sans benefits. Trustee Moran suggested $544,000 from Fund 17 (which has $1.3 million. Fund 17 is for ‘economic uncertainty’ aka a rainy day fund), and $457,000. from the general fund.  

Trustee Butler is encouraging a prudent step as funds may be added at a later date.
Trustee Krumholz asked for what purposes Fund 17 monies may be used. One-time.

The board approved 3-2 (Krumholz, Moran, Severson for, Rossiter and Butler voted against) to deposit funds following Trustee Moran’s suggestion.

Wagner Ranch School Plan – accepted

Northwest Capital Recovery Group: analyzes school district utility bills for errors and line-item expense reductions. Will look at retroactive statements. NWCRG specializes in recovering overcharges in electricity, natural gas, water, sewer, garbage and shredding. Contract unanimously approved.

Parcel Tax Independent Citizens’ Oversight Committee Appointment
Recommended Daniel Pier and Eileen Pummer to fill the four-year term appointments. Unanimously approved.

Glorietta Playground Project
Demolition of existing primary playground, curb and sand area. Will prepare the sub surface and install the pour-in-place surfacing. $98,192.50. Robertson Industries.
Unanimously approved.

District Goals: unanimously approved

Local Control Accountability Plan
Discussion about how to gather public comments.

2014-15 Professional Development Report
Kathy Marshall presented a plethora of staff development concepts for district
Information

Trustee Rossitor asked how information is collected from the teachers. KM responded that the Curriculum Committee collected information over a three-week period from teachers at sites. Information was collated at the October Curriculum Committee Meeting.

Trustee Butler asked if teachers are getting the materials they need in terms of instructional materials. KM assured that teachers have materials. Trustee Severson asked how new teachers are supported in learning Orinda methods. KM affirmed that new teachers receive support from site coaches.

Charles Shannon supported teachers helping teachers.

Board Committee Reports:
·      Trustee Moran met with Dr. Jaconette and Parents’ Club Presidents
·      Fire Drill at DR
·      Dr. Jaconette: Parents’ Club Meetings
·      Science night at Glorietta School on Wednesday, November 5

·      Trustee Butler requested AC and portables’ buyout on a near future agenda and LCAF again on agenda in a couple of months.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

October 13th School Board Update from OEA


Public Comment
Glorietta Teacher: “worst morale for years amongst teachers” – students had art 4 x per month ,  lost ½ of art, and computer teachers and librarians. District makes the choice to limit those programs. Loss of prep time (elementary). Loss of curriculum for students taught by teachers certificated in those areas. “Less regard for teachers and time for teaching is not honored.” “Demonstrate with action and fair compensation that we (teachers) are valued.” See full comments at this link.

Glorietta Teacher: teachers work hard and long hours with enthusiasm and “smiles” for the best interest of their students – teachers help each other- put in extra hours to help students be successful. Many teachers live paycheck to paycheck. 3% last year,  but first salary scale increase in 7 years. July 1st, 2014 medical reduction from $1185 to $915 = 20% decrease.

Charles Shannon, OEA President: SF newspaper quoted re: teacher shortage – jobs are now “less enticing” and attrition is contributing.  Requests that Trustees retain and support Orinda teachers. Here's the article.

Teacher of the Month – Lori Biddle, 5th grade teacher at Glorietta
Classified Employee of the Month – Jennifer Coon (district office)

Kathy Marshall – Resolution 1503: Sufficient Educational Materials
Comment by Charles Shannon. Teachers continue to create transitional CC materials as materials have not been provided by the district
KM: CA state freeze on adoptions until summer 2015
Resolution 1503 adopted: unanimous

KM: School Plan to “coordinate educational plan for all schools and a blueprint” for educational improvements at each site – aligned to LCAP 
- Plans presented for Glo., DR, SH and OIS
Trustee Rossitor asked about differentiation. Principal Theurer described using assessments to group students and addressed the need for time, Principal Gallegos identified using CPT. Principal Randall identified reading grouping, conferencing, on-demands, using instructional assistant for remediation
Trustee Krompholz asked about Bay-Science use. Principal Langer described trained BaySci teachers as leaders for grade levels. KM described various cohorts.
Michael Randall: science is project based
Charles Shannon: differentiated education has created more work for teachers; a lot of demand on our time; informal assesment based on daily work, homework
Trustee Butler thanked teachers who worked on Site Plans
Adopted Site Plans: unanimous



OPEB (Other Post Retirement Benefit Liability for OUSD)
Supplemental lifetime medical benefits for all certificated and classified employees when they retire
OPEB is an expense and if not pre-funded it is referrd to as a liability.  Required by CALPERS. Current district contribution is $119 per month per employees who qualify for this supplement. 1/1/15 contribution will = $122 per month per  qualifying employees. District does not use an irrevocable trust and consequently the cost increases. Earnings from a trust fund investment may reduce future employer OPEB costs. Classified employees’ costs are higher, starting at $295.00-$1185.00. per month.
Trustee Krompholz asked how this item came to be placed on the aganda as an action item when the previous decision included info-gathering.
Trustee Butler asked from where funds for an irrevocable trust would come? Lorene Farrell identified using Fund 17. Trustee Butler asked what $ compose Fund 17. LF: legal settlement $, parcel tax money, start-up $ for WR.
Acalanes UHSD has an irrevocable trust affiliated with CALPERS and Lafayette is investigating a trust.
Trustee Rossitor stated that 83% of districts do not provide lifetime supplemental benefits.
Trustee Moran expressed concern about the growth of the liability; ”unfunded liability is unacceptable,” irrevocable trust may provide flexibility needed to fund + interest from investments; concern that the CDE will continue with “boom-bust” cycle.
Trustee Butler asked for clarity about what $ resources will be used. Trustee Moran responded that the source of funds is a “separate discussion”.
Glorietta Parent cautioned Board that they do not have enough information or analysis to currently create an irrevocable trust.
Charles Shannon OEA recommended a mutual discussion about the trust and the $ resources to fund the trsut out of conern for a hidden agenda.
Trustee Severson: will direct staff: “majority of board indicates interest in setting up an irrevocable trust. Choice of which one might be the best one and a disussion about where the funds are coming from.”

Board Policy 3513.3 Tobacco free schools
Approved unanimous

Item H: computers at WR. has two mobile carts. WRPC will pay to lease from Apple to replace old equipment.
Approved: unanimous

Terra Verde Energy Report: AC at sites will be expensive b/c electrical needs to be replaced to support AC. $1million to 1.5 million per site. Recommends AC. Suggested that solar could help offset the cost of installing AC. Although cautioning prudence,  the Trustees need to move forward in about 4-6 weeks, if OUSD wants AC in place for the 2015-16 school year. Charles Shannon and Colleen Sullivan spoke to current classroom temperatures and value of AC for students based on experience in AC’d portables and data collection re” heat in non-AC classrooms during overtly warm weather.
Ed Silvas: portables – 14 leased district portables; the cost to purchase the 14 portables and bring up to the vendor’s standard is $488,917.00. Can be paid out of developer fees.
Charles  Shannon pointed out that after four years there would be no more cost to the district and asked if there are enough developer fees to finance.
Trustee Krompholz varified that Pulte and developer fees money can be used.

District Goals – Supt:
Discussion item
Charles Shannon: Process for feedback from OEA: expected a draft of goals that could be shared with all membership. Four OEA members attended a meeting and were given a draft from the first draft (after review by Coordinating Council) at the meeting. Asked to comment on goals and not given time to even read draft. A district employee took notes and then submitted incorrect information about an OEA inquiry. OEA believes that communication needs to be attached to each goal or included as a stand-along goal.
Trustee Butler supported communication attached to every goal and reminded Board that at one time communication was a district goal.
Trustee Rossitor supported improved communication in terms of stakeholders receiving information in a timely manner that warrants thoughtful analysis.
Trustee Krompholz commented on Technology section in goals; no goal about student programs especially in reference to extensive Coordinating Council comments about technology goals.


Meeting adjourned

Friday, January 31, 2014

Board Highlights from 1/13/14 Meeting: OEA reports

 Video link to Board Meeting 1.13.2014
Charles Shannon, OEA President invited the School Board Members to the 2/8/14 CTA breakfast.

Employees of the Month: Mike Agers (OIS), Pam Chang IA (SH)

Minutes:  Trustee Butler requested that committee assignments be included in the minutes for the purpose of public transparency. Approved 3-2 (Trustees Krumholz, Butler and Severson approved).

This item was presented as the last item of the evening, however I have chosen to move it to the front of the minutes as it concerns OEA membership. (CS)
Under the PERS benefits “umbrella,” OUSD pays a lifetime $50.00 per month medical supplement to its retirees. About half the Contra Costa districts have these benefits. Loreen Farrell presented this information to the Board with the interest of ending the ongoing supplemen optiont via restructuring the districts benefits with PERS or a new provider. At this point it is unclear whether current retirees would be “grandfathered” and continue receiving the medical supplement. Trustee Moran expressed concern that lifetime benefits will eventually encroach on general fund.
A committee will be formed with OEA and management representation to study the issue. OEA has requested the option of selecting an outside expert who may assist all involved in making a sound decision. To be continued.

Annual Financial Audit Report by Cichella and Tokunaga
The accountants found that OUSD is compliant in its financial accounting as of the close of June, 2013. Available reserve should be at 3%. The auditor found that the school district has reserves of 20%. Report approved 5-0

Interdistrict Transfer Policies
Strustee Butler asked how many transfers accepted from 2012-2014
Employee requests:
2009 – 2010:  23 applied, 21 approved
2010 - 2011:  17 applied, all accepted
2011 – 2012: same as above
2012  - 2013: 15 applied, all accepted
2013 – 2014:  15 applied, all acceptd
Lottery process if more applicants than spaces available, however the lottery includes all requests (employee, locally employed, out-of-district)

Trustee Butler and Trustee Krumholz suggested that “random” (lottery) in ed code could be after a priority. Trustee Butler extensively researched districts in our county in terms of acceptance of employees’ children. Found many other districts to be more conducive.

OEA President pointed out that Pulte Homes has stated in its public documentation that priority will be given to those working in Orinda for a minimum of one year for consideration of below market rate homes. Why may that agency publicize its priority w/o concern for legal action?

An OIS teacher requested priority for teachers.
An OIS employee: out of district students who attend Miramonte are notified of acceptance in April and May and questioned why OUSD waits until the end of August to notify applicants of admittance or denial
Local citizen: asked about fiscal impact
Former student spoke in favor of priority
OIS teacher reminded the district that positive news reports about OUSD are preferable. Private schools recruit teachers at 5-year increments. Employees’ children attending school in OUSD is a strong incentive to remain.

Trustee Severson stated that the OUSD policy was legally challenged and that legal counsel for the district has recommended against any change in policy.
Trustee Butler pointed out that the legal challenge was about the Allen Act, not interdistrict transfer of employees’ children. Trustee Krumholz stated that because the interdistrict transfer has not previously been challenged he is less concerned about that possibility. He sees the opportunity as an amenity that will attract teachers to the district. Trustee Rossiter spoke in favor of the AcalanesUHSD policy where employees’ children are given priority. Trustee Severson, as Board President requested that more legal detail be provided and recognized the Board consensus is for employee support if possible. Dr Jaconette spoke to his concern about possible liability for the district. He also noted that the CCCOE often finds in favor of the child during a transfer appeal.

Common Core Funds designations:
Instructional materials increased from 9% to 19% ($94,345.00)
Staff Development increased from 32% to 49% ($245,860.00)
Technnology reduced from 59% to 32%  ($159,750.00)
CCF is a one-time funds and the allocation is based on enrollment. The aportionment is for two years and must be spent by July 2015.
Technology $ reduction will be supported via Pulte facities funds.
Bandwidth will be a general fund expense; $34,000.00 per year
The OEA Prsident and VP thanked Mrs. Marshall for revisiting and adjusting the percentages for expenditures and emphasized the significant efforts of the district teachers who are creating their own CC transition materials.
Board approved 5-0

 Mr Silvas recommended that the district bandwidth be increased from 100MB to 200MB for the district office at the cost of $22,228.56. Bandwidth is equally available to all school sites, where bandwidth is currently 50MB and will increase to 100MB. Board approved 5-0

Energy planning for the district: use Prop 39, solar and energy efficiency funds
Newcomb, Anderson and McCormick Company
Energy planning, energy efficiency, and solar = $69,970.00
W/o solar = $41,775.00.  Approved total contract 5-0

RGM  Assoc. Project Management
Mr. Silvas recommended RGM, a company that has provided past positive service to OUSD. The purpose is to use the company to manage the Facilities Priority List.
$523,500.    close to $700,000. Projects are expected to take more than one year to complete.  Trustees expressed concern about cost although consider $130.00 per hour for a project manager as a fair rate. Trustee Krumholz pointed out that the amertization equals a full time employee for two years. Approved rate structure 5-0.
Will later approve contract.

Corovan Moving
This company moved the DO to the current location. Mr. Silvas is recommending the same company to move to new district office location: $8,060.38
Approved 4-1 abstention

Mr. Inglesby recommended Goldbook, an online tool that enables a teacher to view student profiles for IEP students and create a differentiated goal with tools and resources to achieve that goal. Goals are measured 3-4 times per year. The program correlates to elec. IEP docs. Goldbook was piloted this fall. Mr. Inglesby reported a positive response from teachers who used the program. Common Core funds can support the adoption purchase.
Approved 5-0

Portables (discussion item): the Board reuested information about costs to buy out the current 14 leased portables and also the cost to replace 31 portables throughout district.
American Modular Gen 7 portables are highly sustainable, energy efficient and meet CHPS and LEED standards for Green Schools. Installed on a 5” slab foundation with steel frame and meet CA seismic regulation. 14 leased = $4,081,200.00.
17 owned = $6,156,000. Solar may be an option on rooftops. There is interest by the Board to improve the portables’ quality in the district. Cost is a significant factor. Discussion to be continued.

Board reports:
Trustee Butler: Advocacy Day meetings
Trustee Severson: bus report
Superintendent Report: complimented business office re: audit, 1/22 state budet meeting at CCCOE
Trustee Butler suggested reviewing school climate/discipline at school sites and requested information about principal’s evaluations

Respectfully submitted by,
Colleen Sullivan

OEA VP